Is It All The Same?

If everyone has an opinion about how the world functions around us, and some of those ideas seemingly are in conflict with each other, then can each of the individual claims still be true? If one person believes something to be true, but another person believes something contrary,  can these two statements both be true? This conflict is seemingly what individuals in our world today appear to be claiming. It is easier to see this conflict if specific examples are given. If I say a personal being created the universe out of nothing, thus had a beginning, but you say the universe is eternal, thus had no beginning,  can we just agree that both of us are right? Or do we, by declaring we are both correct,  destroy all logical principles as we know them?